Getting started with the Meltano 3.7 surge
Meltano offers a CLI-first, open source alternative to Fivetran and Airbyte with over 300 connectors. Developer teams can manage their entire data lifecycle using Python-native orchestration, Singer taps, and dbt transformations within a version controlled project.
Meltano provides 300+ connectors and relies on the Singer data format for source integrations. You can install Meltano on a local machine, in the cloud, or using Docker. To begin, you need Python 3.7 or later. I recommend creating a virtual environment using Python before you install the package via pip. Once you run the command to initiate a project, Meltano creates a directory containing a Meltano.yml file to store your configurations. You can add a CSV extractor by using the terminal to add the extractor to the directory Meltano creates for your source files.
Meltano differs from Fivetran because it uses a CLI-first approach. Developers use the command line interface to build data pipelines and manage source control with Git. This design allows you to create modular structures of code using only the extractors and loaders your system requires. Fivetran operates as a web-based ELT platform with a drag-and-drop interface. Fivetran uses a pricing model based on the consumption of data, specifically Monthly Active Rows. Meltano avoids this pricing model because it is an open source platform. You can use as many connectors as you need without impacting your budget.
| Feature | Meltano | Fivetran |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Interface | CLI-first | Drag-and-drop |
| Connector Count | 300+ | 160+ |
| Pricing Model | Self-hosted/Free | Monthly Active Rows |
| Deployment | Local, Cloud, Docker | SaaS |
Meltano uses dbt for transformations within your databases. You add a dbt transformer to your project using code, and it uses plain SQL to define those transformations. You can add a PostgreSQL loader to your project to export your data. If you need to migrate from Fivetran to Meltano, you must first analyze your existing data sources and targets. You should create a source-to-target mapping document to identify how data transforms. After you move the data, you should validate it using tools like Great Expectations to generate data quality reports.
Comparing Fivetran and Airbyte
Fivetran targets hyper-growth companies by providing fully managed data connectors. It includes over 160 data source connectors and supports change data capture for databases. Fivetran users pay for each data source and destination they use in a pipeline. This dynamic pricing makes budgeting difficult for many teams. Fivetran takes months or years to build new connectors, and it asks clients to script their own solutions using cloud functions if a connector does not exist.
Airbyte provides an open source data integration engine. Airbyte Cloud offers more than 700 connectors across its plans. You can use the Airbyte Connector Development Kit or the no-code Connector Builder to develop your own connections. Airbyte Cloud users access support through in-app chat, Slack, and GitHub. Airbyte Core is free to use, but you must pay the costs for your own infrastructure.
Fivetran wins on reliability because it has more experience with paid customers. It manages its own connectors and provides 24/7 access to technical specialists. Fivetran provides a 99.9 percent platform uptime guarantee for certain plans. Airbyte offers high flexibility, but you must own the infrastructure, the connector upgrades, and the debugging. If you use a self-hosted Airbyte deployment, you must manage the monitoring and the retry logic yourself. Airbyte’s connector retry settings require careful tuning so you do not burn API quotas.
| Capability | Airbyte | Fivetran |
|---|---|---|
| Connector Count | 700+ (Cloud) | 160+ |
| Deployment | Self-hosted, Cloud, Hybrid | SaaS, Hybrid |
| Customization | High (Open Source) | Low (Black Box) |
| Support | Community/Slack/Email | 24/7 Technical Specialists |
The choice between these two depends on your organizational culture. Teams that value predictability often choose Fivetran. Teams that want flexibility and transparency choose Airbyte. Will your team prefer to manage the infrastructure or pay for a managed service?
Implementing Meltano for Developer Teams
Meltano is the best choice for developer-heavy teams that seek an open source framework. You use the command line to configure Singer taps and define targets. This workflow allows you to manage your entire data lifecycle in a single version controlled project. You can integrate Meltano with Apache Airflow for orchestration. Meltano supports the Singer Spec, which is the open source standard for ELT pipelines. You can use the Meltano Singer SDK to build powerful extractors and loaders with minimal code.
The SDK provides several building blocks for your pipelines. You can use the SQLTap class for database sources or the RESTStream class for REST APIs. The Target class serves as the base for all data loaders. You can use a RecordSink to process one record at a time or a BatchSink to process records in batches. The SDK includes built-in authentication classes like OAuth and JWT. It also provides automatic pagination handling and schema validation.
You can find and evaluate connectors on Meltano Hub. Look for connectors that use the Meltano Singer SDK, as these are more likely to be recent and well supported. Check the latest commit timestamp to see if the project is active. If a connector has no commits for over a year, it might be a hobby project. You should also check if the maintainers respond to issues and pull requests within a week.
To add a loader to your Meltano project, use the terminal to add the loader. For a PostgreSQL loader, you run a command to add it to your project. You then edit the Meltano.yml file to add the configurations for your source data. If you want to add a dbt transformer, you add it to your project using code. After you add your extractors, loaders, and transformers, you run the data pipeline command to validate it. The pipeline will read data from your source and load it into your destination.